The Top 5 Mistakes VCE Students Make in Argument Analysis Essays
Introduction
Argument analysis is a key component of VCE English, and yet many students fail to reach top marks because they fall into common traps. The difference between a good essay and a great one often comes down to avoiding these critical mistakes.
Here are the top 5 mistakes VCE students make in argument analysis—and how to avoid them.
Mistake 1: Listing Techniques Without Context
One of the most common errors is simply naming persuasive techniques without explaining their effect. For example:
"The author uses emotive language and statistics to persuade the reader."
This statement tells the reader nothing about how these techniques work or why they're effective.
Tip:
Always explain the intended effect of each technique. Ask yourself: "How does this make the audience feel or think?"
Strong analysis goes beyond identification—it explores the relationship between technique, audience, and purpose.
Mistake 2: Overlooking the Audience
Many students forget to consider who the argument is aimed at. Understanding the audience is crucial because it shapes how persuasive techniques work.
- Who is the intended audience?
- What values, beliefs, or concerns do they hold?
- How is the author appealing to those specific values?
Tip:
Reference the audience explicitly in your analysis. For example: "By appealing to parents' concerns about safety, the author positions them to support stricter regulations."
Audience awareness demonstrates sophisticated understanding of how persuasion works.
Mistake 3: Neglecting the Visuals
VCE argument analysis texts often include images, graphs, or cartoons—and these are not just decoration. They're persuasive tools that deserve analysis.
- What does the visual show?
- How does it complement or reinforce the written argument?
- What emotions or associations does it evoke?
Tip:
Analyse visuals just as carefully as written techniques. Describe what you see, then explain its persuasive purpose.
Ignoring visuals means missing out on easy marks and demonstrating incomplete analysis.
Mistake 4: Weak Structural Flow
A common mistake is treating each paragraph as an isolated observation rather than building a cohesive argument about how the text persuades.
- Use topic sentences to signal the focus of each paragraph
- Link paragraphs together with transitional phrases
- Show how the argument develops or shifts throughout the text
Tip:
Structure your essay to follow the progression of the argument. This creates a logical flow and demonstrates deeper understanding.
Strong structure shows that you understand not just individual techniques, but how they work together.
Mistake 5: Repeating Points
Repetition happens when students identify the same technique or effect multiple times without adding new insight. This wastes valuable words and weakens your analysis.
- Ensure each paragraph offers a distinct point
- Avoid saying "the author persuades the reader" in every sentence
- Vary your vocabulary and sentence structure
Tip:
Plan your essay before writing. Identify 3-4 distinct persuasive strategies and dedicate one paragraph to each.
Variety and depth are more valuable than volume. Make every sentence count.
Final Thought
Avoiding these five mistakes can dramatically improve your VCE argument analysis essays. Focus on explaining techniques in context, considering the audience, analysing visuals, building strong structure, and avoiding repetition.
Remember: Great argument analysis is about depth, not breadth. Analyse fewer techniques more thoroughly rather than listing everything you notice.
Related Articles
How to Break Down a Common Module Essay Question (Step-by-Step Guide)
Master HSC English Common Module essays with this step-by-step guide to analysing questions and planning responses.
VCE Biology: How to Interpret Experimental Data Like a Pro
Master VCE Biology data interpretation with strategies for analysing graphs, tables, and experimental results.